Bill Cosby’s lawyers are arguing in court for a second day that sexual assault charges against the comedian should be dropped because the state declined to prosecute the case more than a decade ago.
Cosby’s lawyers started Wednesday’s hearing by calling lawyer John “Jack” P. Schmitt, who represented Cosby in 2005, to testify that the then-district attorney of Montgomery County, Pennsylvania, declared that Cosby could not be prosecuted in connection with allegations made by Andrea Constand.
The comedian’s lawyers are asking a Pennsylvania judge to dismiss the case, in which Constand — one of a long line of Cosby accusers but among the first to contact authorities — accuses the comedian of assaulting her in his home in 2004.
Cosby was charged in the case in December, 11 years after the state initially declined to prosecute.
In addition to denying the allegations, Cosby argues he’s being improperly prosecuted based on testimony he gave during a civil suit — testimony his defense says was given only because the state closed the criminal case in 2005.
During testimony in the pretrial hearing Tuesday, the prosecutor who declined to charge Cosby in 2005 conceded he believed Pennsylvania was barred from charging Cosby in the Constand case “for all time.”
“Mr. Cosby was not getting prosecuted, at all, ever, as far as I was concerned,” former Montgomery County District Attorney Bruce Castor testified Tuesday. “… I made the decision as the sovereign that Mr. Cosby would not be prosecuted, no matter what.”
As Cosby listened in the courtroom, Castor testified that he did so in part because he didn’t believe the case was strong enough for a conviction.
Castor also said he thought the move might help Constand successfully sue the entertainer. He essentially conceded that the only reason Cosby testified in Constand’s subsequent 2005 civil suit — the very testimony that prosecutors are now using to charge him — was because he took any potential prosecution off the table.
When Castor declined to prosecute in 2005, he said, Cosby couldn’t claim Fifth Amendment protection against self-incrimination in the civil suit.
“Cosby would have had to have been nuts to have said those things (in the civil deposition) if he thought he was going to be prosecuted,” Castor said.
Read more: CNN
- Marine Dakota Meyer Demolishes Transgender Navy SEALS Story…
- 20yr-Old Chick Draws Gun on Man Who Ran Over Her Family Members at Funeral
- Dude Waves Communist Flag at Trump Rally — Watch What Happens to Him Next
- Alert: 18 ‘ISIS Fighters’ Have Been Executed in Libya
- Imran Awan Allegedly Steals House Democrats’ Laptops, is Arrested; DWS Fights With Capitol Police — This is Big
- Hollywood Freaks After Trump Declares No Transgendered People to Serve in Military: ‘You just pissed off the wrong community.’
- Criminal Complaint to be Filed Against Animal Rights Activists Who Threatened Huntress, Leading to Her Suicide
- Illegal Immigrant in New York Charged with Raping 12yr-Old Girl More than Once
- Chris Hemsworth Thinks a Woman Should be the New Bond…
- Gang of 4 Stalk 50yr-Old Woman, ‘Forced Her to Perform Oral Sex at Gunpoint’ [Video]
- ALERT: All US Army M1911 Handguns to be Transferred to Civilian Marksmanship Program in new Bill
- Watch: Revolver or Semi-Auto for a Conceal Carry Weapon?
- Dude Goes on Streaking Rampage After Cutting Off His Penis While High on Drugs [Video]
- Michelle Obama Claims People Don’t Like Her Because of ‘Her Skin Color’
- Berkeley Middle School Teacher Yvette Felarca Arrested For Assault, Rioting At ‘Anti-Fascist’ Protest
- BREAKING: DC Transit Officer Involved with ISIS, Helped Them Get… UPDATE
- Busted: Chick Tries Framing Cop for Sexual Harassment, Then His Body-Cam Footage was Released
- Dear Parents: Would You Enroll Your Kids in a School That Teaches Them to Shoot, Gut and Cook Wild Animals?