So asks a WTOV (Ohio & West Virginia) story:
Does the Second Amendment trump the First?
It’s a question being looked at here in the Ohio Valley after a local newspaper is denied a Freedom of Information request.
The request was made by a reporter for a Wheeling newspaper requesting the names of all the people with a concealed-carry permit.
Ohio County Sheriff Pat Butler says it violates the privacy and safety of many residents. “First of all, I think it’s an invasion of privacy, and I think it’s a dangerous precedent to set to let people all over the Ohio Valley know who has permits and who doesn’t,” Butler said….
Stories about whether one constitutional right “trump[s]” another usually turn on unduly loose understandings of what constitutes a right. This is particularly so in this situation.